Bot Detector
IJPC Seal
Download FREE Sample Issue or Article
LEARN MORE
Subscribe Today
A subscription to IJPC provides on-line access to full-text, full-color, printable PDF copies of your subscribed issues, individual articles, and purchased archives.

Evaluation of the Efficacy and Superiority of Different Vial Rubber Closure Disinfection Techniques

Author(s):  Bjornstad Matthew, Kosinski Tracy, Burlage Robert

Issue:  Sep/Oct 2020 - Volume 24, Number 5
View All Articles in Issue

Page(s):  434-438

Evaluation of the Efficacy and Superiority of Different Vial Rubber Closure Disinfection Techniques Page 1
Evaluation of the Efficacy and Superiority of Different Vial Rubber Closure Disinfection Techniques Page 2
Evaluation of the Efficacy and Superiority of Different Vial Rubber Closure Disinfection Techniques Page 3
Evaluation of the Efficacy and Superiority of Different Vial Rubber Closure Disinfection Techniques Page 4
Evaluation of the Efficacy and Superiority of Different Vial Rubber Closure Disinfection Techniques Page 5

Download in electronic PDF format for $75

Abstract:  Contamination of sterile products has caused significant adverse outcomes in patients, including death. Limited research has been conducted on the efficacy and/or superiority of sterile isopropyl alcohol disinfection techniques of rubber stopper surfaces in sterile compounding. The objective of this evaluation was to investigate the efficacy and/or superiority between the following three disinfecting techniques of vial rubber tops when utilizing sterile isopropyl alcohol wipes: Intervention 1) three swipes back and forth using the same surface; Intervention 2) three swipes in a unidirectional manner using the same surface; Intervention 3) three swipes in a unidirectional manner using a different side of wipe with each swipe. The rubber stopper surfaces of 90 vials were contaminated with bacteria. Thirty vials were disinfected with each assigned technique, swabbed after drying, and plated. After plates were incubated for 48 hours, colonies were quantified, and the different techniques compared. When comparing the varying disinfection techniques to the positive control, Intervention 1 and Intervention 3 techniques showed statistical significance (P=0.00). The Intervention 2 technique showed no difference in colony counts from the positive control (P=0.259). Comparing the different techniques side by side, both Intervention 1 and Intervention 3 techniques were statistically different from the Intervention 2 technique (P=0.027, P=0.00). There was no statistical significance noted between the Intervention 1 and Intervention 3 disinfecting techniques (P=0.141). Disinfecting vials with three swipes in one direction with a different surface of the sterile alcohol wipe or disinfecting vials with a back and forth motion three times is superior to either not disinfecting the vial or disinfecting the vial with three swipes in one direction using the same surface of the sterile alcohol wipe during sterile compounding. 

Related Keywords: Matthew Bjornstad, BS, PharmD, Tracy Kosinski, PharmD, CPPS, BCSCP, Robert Burlage, PhD, compounded sterile preparation, rubber vial stopper surfaces, disinfection techniques, microbial contamination, multi-dose vials, sterile isopropyl alcohol wipes, parenteral preparations

Related Categories: PACKAGING, PEER-REVIEWED, STERILE PREPARATIONS, QUALITY CONTROL

Printer-Friendly Version



Related Articles from IJPC
Title/Author
(Click for Abstract / Details / Purchase)
Issue/​Page
View/Buy
Evaluation of the Efficacy and Superiority of Different Vial Rubber Closure Disinfection Techniques
Bjornstad Matthew
, Kosinski Tracy, Burlage Robert
Sep/Oct 2020
Pg. 434-438

Choosing a Vial Processing Line for Aseptic Compounding: Part 1
Noorian Shaun
, Vahedi Navid
Jul/Aug 2016
Pg. 283-292

Quality Control: How to Produce a Well-closed Sealed Vial in a Regulated CGMP Environment: Part 1
Higgins Doral (Neal) O
, Prudom Melanie J, Summers Amy
Jul/Aug 2021
Pg. 298-302

Basics of Sterile Compounding: Intravenous Admixture Preparation, Part 11: Particulate Issues --- Silicone Oil in Vials, Cartridges, and Syringes
Allen Loyd V Jr
Sep/Oct 2021
Pg. 403-408

How to Qualify Container Closure Systems for Intended Use, Part 1
Kim Amy A
, Gehrmann Matthew R, McCaw James, McAndrew T Page
Nov/Dec 2019
Pg. 454-461

Efficacy and Tolerability of Compounded Bioidentical Hormone Replacement Therapy
Vigesaa Kristy A
, Downhour Nathan P, Chui Michelle A, Cappellini Linda, Musil John D, McCallian Dennis J
Jul/Aug 2004
Pg. 313-319

Quality Control: How to Produce a Well-closed Sealed Vial in a Regulated CGMP Environment: Part 2
Higgins Doral (Neal) O
, Prudom Melanie J, Summers Amy
Sep/Oct 2021
Pg. 389-395

Extending Practical (In Use) Shelf Life of Oncology Drug Vials Using Spikes
de Wilde Sofieke
, Crul Mirjam, Breukels Oscar
Mar/Apr 2023
Pg. 154-159

Incorporating Quality Assurance in Pharmaceutical Compounding-related Courses in the PharmD Curricula
Hossain Mohammad Faisal
, Levesque Dan, Frye John, Rashid Mamoon
Jul/Aug 2020
Pg. 322-326

The Role of Compounding in Closing Therapeutic Gaps--Abstracts from FIP 2013
Lutz Eugene
, Pauletti Giovanni, Carvalho Maria, Davidson Gigi, Ashworth Lisa, Subramaniam Vaiyapuri, Llambí Francesc
Jan/Feb 2014
Pg. 6-12

Basics of Sterile Compounding: Intravenous Admixture Preparation Considerations, Part 10: Packaging and Container-closure Issues
Allen Loyd V Jr
Jul/Aug 2021
Pg. 311-317

Accuracy Considerations in Sterile Compounding
Akers Michael J
Mar/Apr 2017
Pg. 133-142

Technology Spotlight: Respiratory Vial Sealers
Allen Loyd V Jr
Sep/Oct 2003
Pg. 364-365

Single Center Experience with Robot Technologies for Sterile Compounding: A Retrospective Review
Milibari Loay
, Cotugno Michael, Belisle Caryn, Rocchio Megan, Patterson Robert F, Chacon Pablo, Fanikos John, Vo Peter
Jul/Aug 2020
Pg. 346-351

Vial Washers for the Compounding Pharmacy: Ensuring Preparation Safety
Johnson Kain
, Sully Andrew, Anthenat Bruce
Jul/Aug 2014
Pg. 270-276

Development and Validation of a Stability-indicating High-performance Liquid Chromatographic Method for Quantification of Progesterone in Compounded Glycerinated Gelatin Troches
Burrows Anna C
, Yellepeddi Venkata Kashyap, Snyder Spencer, Wakefield Meagan, Jackson David, Huynh Johnny, Nguyen Khoa, Sayre Casey L
Jul/Aug 2019
Pg. 340-350

Safe Cytotoxic Drug Preparation Using a Closed-system Transfer Device: Technical and Practical Evaluation of a New Device (Vialshield/Texium) Comparatively to a Reference One (Phaseal)
Garrigue Philippe
, Montana Marc, Ventre Christophe, Savry Amadine, Gauthier-Villano Laurence, Pisano Pascale, Pourroy Bertrand
Mar/Apr 2016
Pg. 148-154

Sterile Basics of Compounding: Relationship Between Syringe Size and Dosing Accuracy
Kosinski Tracy M
, Brown Michael C, Zavala Pedro J
Jan/Feb 2018
Pg. 41-46

Compounding in the Pharmacy Curriculum: Beyond the Basics
Hinkle Amanda R
, Newton Gail D
May/Jun 2004
Pg. 181-185

Rheologic Profile, Specific Gravity, Surface Tension, and pH of Fifteen Over-the-Counter Preparations
Al-Achi Antoine
, Baghat Tushar, Chukwubeze Onah, Dembla Ishwin
May/Jun 2007
Pg. 252-258

Return to Top